Comparison
Keel vs Super Monitoring
This page is for people watching a handful of URLs who searched "Super Monitoring alternative" and want to know whether the smaller tool does the job — not for anyone who needs content matching, form testing, or SMS credits, because Super Monitoring does those and Keel doesn't, and we'd rather say so.
The comparison
Super Monitoring's figures below are from their pricing page as of November 2026 — USD amounts as served to us. Keel's are from ours. Both will drift; the shape of the difference won't.
| What you get | Keel | Super Monitoring |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Single-purpose uptime monitor. Nothing else, on purpose. | Website monitoring service running since 2010: availability, response time, content (phrase matching), form testing, file integrity, transaction, page loading time, change, Core Web Vitals, domain expiry, and SSL monitoring. |
| Free tier | 3 monitors, 5-minute checks, webhook alerts, 30-day history. | No free plan. A 14-day free trial, no installation or billing data required. |
| Paid pricing | £5/month flat — 50 monitors, 60-second checks. No seats, no add-ons, no usage tiers. | Five plans, all with 1-minute max testing frequency: Super $5.99/month (1 check), Hyper $14.99 (3 checks), Extra $19.99 (5 checks), Ultra $29.99 (10 checks), Multi $39.99 (20 checks). Annual billing is cheaper — e.g. Super is $59/year against $71.88 paid monthly [ESTIMATE: 12 × $5.99]. Additional SMS credits are $7 per 100. |
| Alerting | Webhooks only — down, up, or both, to any HTTPS endpoint, on every plan including Free. Payloads are plain JSON, so Slack, Discord, and curl work without adapters. Failed deliveries retry once. | Instant email and SMS alerts on every plan, with unlimited alert recipients. SMS runs on credits — a bundle is included per plan and $7 buys another 100 (in the USA, 1 SMS = 1 credit). No webhook or chat-integration channel is listed on the pricing page. |
| Incident threshold | Two consecutive failures open an incident; one blip is ignored on purpose. The first passing check closes it and fires up. | Not published as a single number; alerts go out per the notification settings on each check. |
| Check types | HTTP and HEAD, against a status code you choose. Redirects are not followed — a 3xx counts as down unless you set it as the expected code. | Availability, response time, content phrase matching, web form testing, file integrity (checksums), transaction, page loading time, change monitoring, Core Web Vitals, domain expiry, SSL certificate, blacklist, and e-commerce monitoring. |
| Status pages | Not offered. | Public status pages listed under "Other Features", with greater customization on higher plans. |
| History | 30 days of every check — status, status code, latency, error text. | Unlimited retention of event history; screenshots and HTML snapshots kept 1 year, HAR files shorter (per their pricing-page footnote). |
When Keel is the better fit
When the URLs are few and the webhook is the point.
Any monitors at all, for free, forever
Super Monitoring's cheapest plan is $5.99/month for exactly one check; there is no free tier, only a 14-day trial. Keel's free plan is 3 monitors with webhook alerts and no expiry — for a personal site or two, that's the whole job done for nothing.
Fifty monitors is still one flat price
Twenty checks on Super Monitoring is the Multi plan at $39.99/month. Fifty monitors at 60-second checks on Keel is £5/month flat — roughly a tenth of the price as served here, and the schedule is enforced server-side either way.
Your alert pipeline is the webhook
Keel's webhook is on every plan including Free — plain JSON with a readable summary plus the full monitor, check, and incident objects, so Slack, Discord, and curl all consume it without adapters. Super Monitoring's pricing page lists email and SMS only; no webhook or chat channel is listed.
One blip shouldn't wake anyone
Keel opens an incident after two consecutive failures, deliberately: a single timeout is usually noise, and noise that wakes you is a cost. The first passing check closes the incident and fires up, so the alert always matches the history you can see.
When Super Monitoring is the better fit
Often, honestly — a decade-and-a-half of monitoring features earns its corners.
Content, forms, and transactions
Phrase matching catches a page that returns 200 with the wrong words on it; form testing submits your contact form end to end; transaction monitoring walks multi-step flows. Keel checks a status code you choose, and nothing else.
SMS and unlimited alert recipients
Instant email and SMS on every plan, with as many recipients as needed — a phone that buzzes without anyone writing a receiver. Keel has no SMS by design; its webhook is the entire alerting surface.
Speed, Core Web Vitals, and change detection
Page loading time, Core Web Vitals, website change monitoring, and file integrity via checksums, with screenshots and HTML snapshots kept for a year as evidence. Keel records status, status code, latency, and error text, and keeps 30 days of it.
1-minute checks at the entry price
Every Super Monitoring plan runs at up to 1-minute testing frequency, starting at $5.99/month. Keel's free tier is 5-minute and its paid tier is 60-second at £5/month — if the budget is under a fiver and 1-minute matters, their entry plan wins that specific trade.
Pick the small one on purpose.
If you need content matching, form tests, or SMS alerting, use Super Monitoring — it's the better tool for that. If you need a handful of URLs watched and a webhook fired when they break, that's £5/month and about a minute of setup.
The webhook payload and public API are documented at keelmonitor.com/docs; the two-line price list lives at keelmonitor.com/#pricing.