Comparison

Keel vs OnlineOrNot

This page is for people watching a handful of URLs who searched "OnlineOrNot alternative" and want to know whether the smaller tool does the job — not for anyone who needs browser checks or a status page, because OnlineOrNot ships both and Keel ships neither, and we'd rather say so.

The comparison

OnlineOrNot's figures below are from their pricing page as of October 2026 — USD amounts as served to us. Keel's are from ours. Both will drift; the shape of the difference won't.

What you getKeelOnlineOrNot
What it is Single-purpose uptime monitor. Nothing else, on purpose. Uptime and browser-check monitoring from the maker of a WordPress plugin — static site checks, rendered-page checks, and status pages, built for teams shipping sites.
Free tier 3 monitors, 5-minute checks, webhook alerts, 30-day history. Hobby, free: 3 uptime monitors at 3-minute checks, 1,000 browser check runs a month, up to 2 users, a limited status page (1, custom logo, 100 email subscribers), email plus Slack/Discord/Telegram alerts, 14-day data retention.
Paid pricing £5/month flat — 50 monitors, 60-second checks. No seats, no add-ons, no usage tiers. Pro from $15/month: 10 monitors included (+$10 per additional 25), 3,000 browser check runs (+$4 per additional 1,000), 30-second checks, unlimited users, SMS, webhooks, on-call integrations, status page with custom domain, 12-month retention. Extra status pages $24/month each. Enterprise is custom.
Uptime, API, browser-check, and cron-job monitoring with status pages and alert routing — a full monitoring stack, not just a pinger. Webhooks only — down, up, or both, to any HTTPS endpoint, on every plan including Free. Payloads are plain JSON, so Slack, Discord, and curl work without adapters. Failed deliveries retry once. Email plus Slack, Discord, and Telegram on the free plan; webhooks, SMS, and on-call integrations arrive with Pro.
Incident threshold Two consecutive failures open an incident; one blip is ignored on purpose. The first passing check closes it and fires up. Not published as a single number on the pricing page; alerts follow the monitor's configuration.
Check types HTTP and HEAD, against a status code you choose. Redirects are not followed — a 3xx counts as down unless you set it as the expected code. Uptime monitors plus real browser checks — rendered pages, not just status codes — with maintenance windows on Pro and above.
Status pages Not offered. 1 on Hobby (limited, custom logo allowed, 100 email subscribers) and 1 on Pro with custom domain and unlimited subscribers; more pages $24/month each, private pages $48/month each.
History 30 days of every check — status, status code, latency, error text. 14 days on Hobby; 12 months on Pro.

When Keel is the better fit

When the URLs are few and the webhook is the point.

You want one price, not a base plus runners

OnlineOrNot Pro starts at $15/month with 10 monitors and meters the rest — +$10 per 25 monitors, +$4 per 1,000 browser runs, $24 per extra status page. Keel is £5/month flat for 50 monitors at 60-second checks: the whole schedule, enforced server-side, and the bill cannot surprise you.

The alert should just be a webhook

On OnlineOrNot, webhooks are a Pro feature; the free plan alerts by email and chat apps. On Keel the webhook is on every plan including Free — plain JSON with a readable summary plus the full monitor, check, and incident objects, down/up/both per channel, a test send, and one retry on failure.

One blip shouldn't wake anyone

Keel opens an incident after two consecutive failures, deliberately: a single timeout is usually noise, and noise that wakes you is a cost. The first passing check closes the incident and fires up, so the alert always matches the history you can see.

You'd rather not provision a team

Seats, browser-run quotas, maintenance windows, subscriber lists — OnlineOrNot is priced for a team shape. Keel has nothing to provision: add a URL, choose the expected status code, point a webhook at it, done — the free tier is playable without paying anything.

When OnlineOrNot is the better fit

Often, honestly — the browser-check gap is the big one.

Your site lies when it's broken

OnlineOrNot runs real browser checks — rendered pages with JavaScript — so a white-screen SPA with a 200 status gets caught. Keel reads the status code and nothing else: a page that renders garbage while returning 200 looks healthy to us. On truthful detection, they win.

Faster free checks and chat alerts for nothing

The Hobby plan checks every 3 minutes against Keel's 5, and includes Slack, Discord, and Telegram alerts alongside email. On free speed and free alert breadth, they win outright.

Status pages, SMS, and on-call

A status page on every plan — custom domain and unlimited email subscribers on Pro — plus SMS and on-call integrations up the ladder. Keel has no status pages and no SMS, and if customers expect status.yourdomain.com, Keel isn't the tool.

Teams and a year of history

Unlimited users on Pro with 12-month data retention and audit logs, against Keel's 30 days and single-operator shape. If the postmortem needs last quarter, that's OnlineOrNot's category.

Pick the small one on purpose.

If you need browser checks, status pages, SMS alerts, or team seats, use OnlineOrNot — it's the better tool for that. If you need a handful of URLs watched and a webhook fired when they break, that's £5/month and about a minute of setup.

The webhook payload and public API are documented at keelmonitor.com/docs; the two-line price list lives at keelmonitor.com/#pricing.